ShrimpTempura

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 12 March 2013

Perceptions of Seafood Sustainability

Posted on 00:00 by Unknown
“One thing about which fish know exactly nothing is water, since they have no anti-environment which would enable them to perceive the element they live in.”
--Marshall McLuhan

This was the second conference I attended at the International Boston Seafood Show where it was mentioned how the media distorts the risks of seafood, though they were in different contexts. In the previous case, it was used in the case where the media emphasizes the minor risk of consuming seafood while failing to give proper coverage to all of the health benefits of seafood. In this conference, the media was alleged to be trying to tie in health risks into the sustainability issue, again greatly exaggerating any such risks.

I attended the What the Industry Experts Say: Perceptions of Sustainable Seafood Production and Marketing conference, which was presented by Wendy Weisman and Tracy Van Holt, who are working together on the SustainableCFood project. They conduct research, trying to determine significant communication gaps that exist in the topic of sustainable seafood. This conference was even part of their research, involving an anonymous survey and a discussion on sustainability issues. So, it was a very interactive session, and there were roughly 25 or so attendees.

Wendy Weisman

It is obvious that there are significant communication gaps in the discussion of sustainability. So many people define the term differently, often based on their own needs and experience. Trying to reach some sort of consensus on a definition is a worthy, though difficult, goal. In researching these issues, Wendy and Tracy engage in "cultural consensus analysis." Tracy stated that "shared knowledge equals culture," a reason why they have chosen a cultural consensus analysis.

That process is similar to the use of focus groups but it also allows each person's voice to be considered individually. The analysis seeks to determine the areas where people agree and disagree on these definitions and issues. They also engage in news analysis, determining what the media says on the topic, both the regular media and the trade.

You can take their survey online though I am unsure of the actual value of the survey. I found a number of the questions to be too vague or confusing so it seems the answers might not reflect true perceptions. It was clear from our discussion of answers to those questions that many people wanted to clarify their answers, that the answers were not as simple as the questions permitted. Instead, I believe the questions are much more useful in starting conversations about these issues. That seems to be a more valuable reason to present the questions rather than seeking the truth of any such question.

Tracy Van Holt 

The discussion moved onto an analysis of news articles dealing with sustainability. The regular media has created the allegation that sustainability in fisheries has a lot to do with important health issues. For example, they promote ideas such as wild seafood is safer for you than farmed seafood. They highlight mistrust and mislabeling, creating the impression that sustainability is unprofitable. The trade media though does not connect sustainability and health. Rather, they emphasize issues of transparency and trust, promoting that sustainability is profitable.

In further media research, they examined Seafood Source and learned that the dominant conversation concerning sustainable revolved around certification. It was also learned that this discussion was often separate from a discussion of fishers. On a related issue, they examined the question of who the media saw as responsible for creating and promoting sustainable fisheries and both the regular media and the trade were in agreement that Companies were most important.

There was an intriguing aside, analyzing the effectiveness of a logo. I thought that the Brunswick Catch logo was the most effective, and I ended up in agreement with their prior survey. What seemed to matter to the public was a logo with the name of the place, that showed a fishermen as well as his gear.

Trying to reach a consensus of sustainability definitions is a worthy and necessary endeavor so discussions in this area are warranted. It is also a glaring issue that media depictions of seafood are negatively slanted and that is an area where the seafood industry needs to take charge and present a more balanced view. That is also part of what I do, trying to present more balanced articles for the average reader. More people need to eat seafood and they should not be scared away from eating it due to the drastic exaggeration of any minor risks.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Boston, ibss13, science, seafood, sustainability | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Tuscan Market: One Stop Shopping & Cafe
    Many of us would love to be able to easily purchase fresh baked bread, fresh local produce, artisan cheese, meats, seafood, fresh pasta, win...
  • Barons de Rothschild Champagnes: A "Drops of God" Rave
    " Champagne is something to enjoy ." -- Philippe Sereys de Rothschild , Chairman of  Champagne Barons de Rothschild . There is mor...
  • The Drops of God: Volume 2
    Could you identify a wine based on a painting that showed a nature scene? That is the dilemma that faces our protagonist,  Shizuku Kanzaki. ...
  • The Drops of God: From A Fangirl’s POV
    ( Today, I present a guest post from Cynette,  a content writer for  Wine Cellar Innovations . As you likely know, I have been giving rave r...
  • Thursday Sips & Nibbles
    I am back again with a new edition of Thursday Sips & Nibbles, my regular column where I briefly highlight some interesting wine and foo...
  • International Boston Seafood Show: Fish Fun & Photos
    “ Fish is held out to be one of the greatest luxuries of the table and not only necessary, but even indispensable at all dinners where there...
  • Happy Thanksgiving: Be Thankful For All You Have
    Today is Thanksgiving, a holiday when many of us will get together with family and friends to share good food and drink. Besides enjoying th...
  • Rant: Wine Bloggers, I Call You Out Once Again
    Last year at this time, I threw down a gauntlet and issued a challenge to all wine bloggers . In the comments, in emails, and on Twitter, so...
  • Halter Ranch Vineyard: SIP & Sip
    Two years ago, I visited the Paso Robles region and was especially impressed with many of their Rhône -style wines, made from a variety of...
  • Wednesday Sips & Nibbles
    I am here with a special Wednesday edition of Sips & Nibbles, my regular column where I briefly highlight some interesting wine and food...

Categories

  • 2011 (8)
  • 2012 (9)
  • 2013 (2)
  • alabama (1)
  • alaska (1)
  • alcohol (1)
  • allergy (1)
  • alsace (3)
  • Andover (3)
  • animal (1)
  • anniversary (1)
  • Argentina Wines (10)
  • Arlington (11)
  • armenia (1)
  • art (4)
  • Australia Wines (2)
  • austria wines (5)
  • author (12)
  • award (2)
  • Bacon (1)
  • Bakery (15)
  • bar (1)
  • bbq (3)
  • beauty (1)
  • Bedford (2)
  • beer (19)
  • biodynamic wine (1)
  • biography (1)
  • blogging (35)
  • Book reviews (30)
  • book store (3)
  • Boston (165)
  • bourbon (11)
  • braintree (2)
  • brazil wines (1)
  • brazilian (1)
  • breakfast (2)
  • brewery (6)
  • brighton (1)
  • Brookline (9)
  • brunch (15)
  • Burlington (3)
  • business (1)
  • butcher (4)
  • California Wines (20)
  • Cambridge (29)
  • canada (8)
  • Canada Wines (7)
  • candy (3)
  • cape cod (6)
  • cape verde wines (1)
  • casino (7)
  • caviar (1)
  • celebrity (2)
  • champagne (11)
  • Charity (33)
  • cheese (23)
  • chef (27)
  • chianti classico (10)
  • children (2)
  • Chile (2)
  • Chile Wines (2)
  • china (6)
  • chinatown (3)
  • chinese cuisine (8)
  • chocolate (1)
  • christmas (3)
  • cider (8)
  • cocktails (47)
  • colorado (2)
  • concord (10)
  • conference (9)
  • Connecticut (12)
  • consumers (2)
  • contest (8)
  • controversy (97)
  • cookbooks (5)
  • cooking (15)
  • cuba (1)
  • cyprus wines (1)
  • dance (1)
  • Danvers (2)
  • dessert wine (1)
  • desserts (21)
  • diet (2)
  • dining service (1)
  • discount (1)
  • distillery (14)
  • dlw13 (1)
  • donuts (1)
  • dorchester (16)
  • easter (6)
  • Eating Habits (2)
  • ebook (6)
  • ethics (3)
  • ethiopia (1)
  • farming (10)
  • father's day (1)
  • fiction (11)
  • finger lakes (2)
  • florida (1)
  • Food (4)
  • Food Event (8)
  • Food Market (12)
  • food news (2)
  • food processing (2)
  • food safety (4)
  • food truck (1)
  • France (3)
  • France Wines (19)
  • fruit (7)
  • Games (2)
  • gardening (1)
  • georgia wines (1)
  • gin (1)
  • glasses (1)
  • grapes (4)
  • Greece Wines (1)
  • guest post (1)
  • health (21)
  • history (34)
  • holiday (46)
  • hotel (2)
  • Hungary Wines (3)
  • hybrid (2)
  • ibss12 (14)
  • ibss13 (13)
  • Ice Cream (5)
  • ice wine (2)
  • iceland (1)
  • interview (5)
  • ipswich (4)
  • ireland (2)
  • italian cuisine (43)
  • Italy (19)
  • Italy Wines (38)
  • jamaica plain (1)
  • japanese (70)
  • kentucky (12)
  • korea (1)
  • law (13)
  • legend (9)
  • lincoln (6)
  • liqueur (1)
  • local wine (2)
  • los angeles (1)
  • louisiana (2)
  • louisville (7)
  • lynnfield (1)
  • madeira (1)
  • magazine (16)
  • Maine (2)
  • Malbec (1)
  • Malden (1)
  • mallorca (1)
  • mardi gras (2)
  • Massachusetts (4)
  • Massachusetts Wines (6)
  • mead (5)
  • meat (23)
  • Medford (6)
  • melrose (3)
  • mexican cuisine (16)
  • mexico wine (3)
  • mezcal (1)
  • milk (2)
  • milton (1)
  • mississippi (1)
  • montreal (2)
  • mothers day (1)
  • music (4)
  • natick (1)
  • needham (3)
  • new england (2)
  • New Hampshire (17)
  • new year's eve (10)
  • New York (3)
  • New York City (3)
  • New York wines (1)
  • New Zealand Wines (1)
  • newburyport (1)
  • newport (1)
  • news (1)
  • newspaper (7)
  • newton (9)
  • North Andover (16)
  • north end (12)
  • nova scotia (5)
  • Oregon (2)
  • Oregon Wines (6)
  • organic food (1)
  • organic wine (2)
  • paso robles (3)
  • peruvian cuisine (1)
  • phillipines (2)
  • pinotage (2)
  • pisco (1)
  • Pizza (2)
  • pork (3)
  • port (13)
  • portland (1)
  • portsmouth (6)
  • Portugal (6)
  • Portugal Wines (19)
  • poultry (1)
  • providence (1)
  • provincetown (5)
  • quebec (5)
  • rant (97)
  • Reading (1)
  • Recipe (11)
  • Restaurant (198)
  • restaurant going (8)
  • restaurant reviews (65)
  • Rhode island (4)
  • rose (7)
  • rum (11)
  • Sake (61)
  • Sake Reviews (15)
  • salem (2)
  • salmon (4)
  • sandwich (5)
  • science (10)
  • scotland (4)
  • seafood (72)
  • Seattle (1)
  • sherry (10)
  • shochu (1)
  • shopping (3)
  • social media (1)
  • soda (2)
  • Somerville (13)
  • South Africa Wines (7)
  • spain (8)
  • Spain Wines (18)
  • sparkling wines (6)
  • spirits (42)
  • sports (4)
  • st. patrick's day (4)
  • steakhouse (12)
  • sudbury (1)
  • sushi (5)
  • sustainability (61)
  • sweden (1)
  • tastecamp (5)
  • tea (6)
  • television (4)
  • tequila (2)
  • texas (1)
  • thai (2)
  • thanksgiving (9)
  • theater (2)
  • top ten (14)
  • toronto (1)
  • travel (8)
  • twitter (1)
  • united states (1)
  • Uruguay Wines (1)
  • valentine's day (5)
  • vegetables (3)
  • vermont (4)
  • virginia (1)
  • virginia wines (1)
  • vodka (8)
  • Wakefield (1)
  • walpole (2)
  • watertown (1)
  • wayland (1)
  • wbc (3)
  • west concord (1)
  • westwood (1)
  • whiskey (19)
  • Winchester (14)
  • Wine (3)
  • Wine Education (19)
  • wine event (14)
  • wine importers (1)
  • wine marketing (11)
  • Wine news (3)
  • wine pairings (15)
  • wine personality (1)
  • Wine Prices (5)
  • Wine Reviews (68)
  • wine sales (13)
  • Wine Stores (23)
  • Wine tasting (11)
  • wine writing (1)
  • winemaker (4)
  • winemaking (6)
  • wineries (5)
  • winery (21)
  • Woburn (3)
  • women (3)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (171)
    • ►  September (5)
    • ►  August (19)
    • ►  July (18)
    • ►  June (19)
    • ►  May (19)
    • ►  April (20)
    • ▼  March (32)
      • The Fish Head Whisperer Reigns Supreme
      • Shojo: Tempura Pickles to Chocolate Sesame Balls
      • Thursday Sips & Nibbles
      • Savoring Michter's Original Sour Mash Whiskey:
      • The Fugu Food Truck Is Coming!
      • Rant: Forget Robert Parker, Celebrities Have The P...
      • Importance Of Wine Sales By The Glass
      • Thursday Sips & Nibbles
      • Rodizio Grill in Braintree
      • Once A Critic, Always a Critic
      • New England Food Show: Some Thoughts
      • Rant: You're Fat & It Is Your Fault
      • All About The International Boston Seafood Show 2013
      • U.S. Aquaculture Advocacy
      • Eat More U.S. Seafood: The Gulf Coast
      • International Boston Seafood Show: Fish Fun & Photos
      • International Boston Seafood Show: Some Highlights
      • Thursday Sips & Nibbles
      • International Boston Seafood Show: Food of Interest
      • Verlasso Salmon: An Update
      • International Boston Seafood Show: Japan Pavilion
      • Perceptions of Seafood Sustainability
      • Rant: Stop Worrying, Seafood is Safe
      • Rant: Wake Up Japan, Bluefin Are In Danger!
      • SeaShare: Seafood For Hungry Americans
      • The Flavors of Los Angeles: Cafe Dulce, N/Naka, Ni...
      • The Tipsy Sensei & Others. And A Contest!
      • Joining The Drink Local Wine Board
      • Thursday Sips & Nibbles
      • Adrian Bridge, Fladgate & How Port Facilitates Con...
      • Rant: Get Thee To The Seafood Show!
      • Gascon Winery: Malbec To Give People Joy
    • ►  February (20)
    • ►  January (19)
  • ►  2012 (283)
    • ►  December (21)
    • ►  November (23)
    • ►  October (30)
    • ►  September (17)
    • ►  August (26)
    • ►  July (23)
    • ►  June (19)
    • ►  May (21)
    • ►  April (20)
    • ►  March (34)
    • ►  February (26)
    • ►  January (23)
  • ►  2011 (46)
    • ►  December (27)
    • ►  November (19)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile